My criteria include:
Price. I will rate with $ for 20 or less, $$ for $21-$50 and $$$ for $51 plus. This will reflect full retail price, and not any sales, discounts or deals you might find, but these will be noted.
Fit. For reference, I am just a hair under 5'6" and a size 0-4 depending on my mood and the clothes, and wear a waist size 25 in pants that use this highly superior sizing system (cough, gap, cough). The rating will include what size I have and how it works.
Feel. Over all comfort.
Foam pit. I work with kids. I spend time around foam almost every day, and I don't need to take it home with me.
Sweat. How do they do in hot yoga? I often go from studio to gym to studio to gym and I want pants that can make a quick transition.
I've also divided things into categories:
High Waist (which I think are pretty much superior to just about anything else)
Regular Legging
Sweat Pants
(I have a couple pairs of shorts, but 1. it's not a priority right now and 2. I'm not super particular about them, so I'm not going to be reviewing them right now)
I will * my top pick in each category
High Waist
*Girlfriend Collective
- Price: $$$, however, they are currently running a deal where you are only paying for shipping from their factory, and it's $20. I highly recommend this before the opportunity runs out!
- Fit: I ordered an XS and they fit perfectly.
- Feel: These are so soft! Definitely high quality feel.
- Foam Pit: No foam pit at home for me!
- Sweat: They stay nice and dry, no matter how hot or humid the room. I can run to the store or whatever right after and not feel gross
90 Degrees by Reflex
- Price: $, and prime shipping from amazon
- Fit: XS, fits great, nice and long to tuck under my heel
- Feel: Nothing special
- Foam Pit: No pit here!
- Sweat: They rate surprisingly well here. I didn't expect much, but they hold up quite well in that hot room.
Old Navy Active Go Dry
- Price: $
- Fit: XS, great, extra long
- Feel: nothing special, like the 90 Degrees
- Foam Pit: plays nice
- Sweat: Again, better than expected
Alo High Waisted Airbrush
Note: I technically only have these in navy, but you'll here why I wouldn't order the black
- Price: $$$
- Fit: XS, a little gapey in the back sometimes
- Feel: A little thicker than other leggings
- Foam Pit: Attack of the pit pieces! It is my biggest problem with Alo.
- Sweat: Good but not great
Regular Legging
*Old Navy Active
- Price: $
- Fit: XS, great
- Feel: So freaking soft
- Foam pit: No issues
- Sweat: Awesome
Fabletics Salar Capri
- Price: $$
- Fit: XXS, good. In general I don't like capris, but these came free with something else so why not.
- Feel: Pretty average
- Foam Pit: Nothing
- Sweat: Good. They can feel a little thick or heavy, but they do stay dry.
Alo Coast Legging
- Price: $$$
- Fit: S. I got them from a coworker who couldn't return them. They fit fine, but an XS would probably be better
- Feel: These have mesh detail and stirrups and are pretty soft to boot!
- Foam Pit: the pit hates these pants
- Sweat: Pretty good. This is one of the lighter feeling alo leggings to me and a favorite of mine in the hot room
Lululemon Reversible Wunder Under
- Price: $$$
- Fit: A 4 works great here
- Feel: Soft, but nothing special
- Foam Pit: nothing too crazy, a mild attraction
- Sweat: they can feel a little warm, but mostly keep it dry
*Onzie Women's Long Legging
- Price: $$
- Fit: XS. It says long, but I think they're pretty normal.
- Feel: My favorite part - they're so light they feel like you're not wearing pants!
- Foam Pit: no attraction
- Sweat: Super quick drying
Gap Active Mesh Detail
note: totally not what they are called, but I don't know so I'm just being descriptive
- Price: $$$
- Fit: S, a little weird around the ankles
- Feel: So soft. The mesh is so minimal that it's not weird or scratchy or anything
- Foam pit: pretty good
- Sweat: A little thick, pretty dry
Sweat Pants
Note: in general, I dislike sweatpants. However, there are times when it comes in handy to have a pair you like. I tried two pairs.
Alo Revive Pant
- Price: $$$
- Fit: S, roomy and comfy
- Feel: crazy soft
- Foam pit: much better than expected
- Sweat: n/a
*Champion Jogger
- Price: $$
- Fit: S, Elizabeth told me they were too big
- Feel: Not crazy soft, but cozy enough
- Foam pit: no issues
- Sweat: n/a
To recap: If you're still reading this, get your butt over to Girlfriend Collective and order yourself the best $20 leggings you'll find. Beyond that, may the odds be ever in your favor.